Two sides of the same logic
Theft and minor offenses were often punished more leniently: the defendant was seen as led by others, acting under someone else's influence or out of need.
Crimes against a husband or against order in the home were punished especially harshly: they were seen as an attack not on a person, but on the structure of society.
Both sides grew from the same root. If women were assumed to have less independence, they were held less responsible for ordinary wrongdoing, and an act that challenged this assigned role looked all the more serious.
This also led to distinct offenses that did not exist for men at all. For centuries, many legal systems treated crimes against a husband or head of household as especially serious and prescribed a separate punishment for them.
What changed over time
Special offenses. Separate crimes and separate punishments tied to the defendant's position in the family.
Formal equality. Gradually, special offenses are abolished, and the law stops distinguishing between defendants by sex.
Inequality in practice. Formal equality remains, but studies document systematic differences in actual sentences.
Analyze the causes. The difference is linked not to the law itself, but to decisions at every step: whom the police detain, whom they charge, and whom they grant a postponement.
The third step has been studied in the greatest detail. Research from different countries shows more lenient punishments for comparable acts, while a significant part of the difference is explained by factors taken into account, such as having children, prior convictions, and a role in a group offense.
But not everything is explained. Some differences remain even after such factors are taken into account, and that remainder is disputed: some see it as leniency, while others see it as the flip side of the same old ideas about what a woman should be.
There is another dimension: conditions of incarceration. There are fewer women's facilities, they are farther from home, and contact with children is lost more often; even with a formally equal sentence, the consequences of punishment can still be different.
Finish reading in the Miqo app
1 more minute, then a quiz at the end. Find it under “Crime → Women Criminals”
Point your phone camera here to open the App Store or Google Play.
Sources
- Historical legal systems provided for special offenses and punishments linked to a woman's position in the family
- after such rules were formally abolished, studies continue to document differences in the punishments imposed, some of which are explained by circumstances taken into account in the case