One mistake, two different reactions
You forgot about a day that mattered to your friend. Two things can happen next, almost indistinguishable from the outside. In one case, you keep replaying the episode: you didn't text, didn't call, she was waiting. In the other, you keep replaying yourself: what kind of friend am I after that, I'm always like this.
The words get muddled here. People use "ashamed" and "guilty" interchangeably in conversation, and you can't tell from one phrase what someone is feeling. Most often, both feelings come together - the question is which one outweighs the other. The difference shows up not in the words, but in what happens next.
Yesterday, I snapped at my daughter over something trivial.
And how did you feel afterward?
Like I'm a terrible mother. I couldn't even look at her all evening.
What if you put it differently: I yelled at her, and it was unfair?
Then I'd go apologize. Instead, I just went into another room.
You can hear the shift here. As long as the judgment is "I'm a terrible mother," there's nothing to do: you can't remake yourself in one evening. As soon as it returns to "I yelled at her," an action appears, and it has someone it's directed toward.
Where the judgment lands
Psychologists describe these as different targets of the same judgment. Helen Block Lewis proposed the distinction in 1971, and it has stuck ever since: guilt targets behavior, shame targets the self. There are steps in between these two targets.
- This is me
- I'm that person
- I did that
- That one time
At the bottom is a specific incident, at the top is you as a whole. The higher the judgment moves, the less there is to repair: an action has someone it's directed toward and a way to make amends, while "this is me" has neither.
That is why guilt usually pushes you toward people, while shame pushes you away from them. June Tangney and her colleagues showed this across many samples: a tendency toward guilt is linked to apologies and empathy, while a tendency toward shame is linked to avoidance, defensiveness, and anger. These are self-reports and correlations, so the pattern is robust but not ironclad: shame is not always destructive, and guilt is not always helpful.
The target is the action. It makes you want to repair things: apologize, redo it, return to the person.
The target is you. It makes you want to disappear: look away, not call, change the subject.
Finish reading in the Miqo app
1 more minute, then a quiz at the end. Find it under “Psychology → Shame and Guilt”
Point your phone camera here to open the App Store or Google Play.
Sources
- Helen Block Lewis, "Shame and Guilt in Neurosis" (1971)
- June Tangney and Ronda Dearing, "Shame and Guilt" (2002)