Why thoughts about yourself sound like someone talking to you
Notice how you think about yourself on a bad day. “What do you think you’re doing?”, “Pull yourself together,” “Again, you’re doing everything halfway.” For some reason, thoughts about yourself address you as “you” - as if there’s someone else in your head commenting. Descriptions aren’t phrased that way. Addresses are.
Psychologist Lev Vygotsky described where this form comes from. At ages 3-5, a child comments aloud on what she’s doing: “Okay, now red, careful, don’t spill.” The words often aren’t her own - they’re an adult’s phrasing and intonation, which the child applies to herself. Closer to school age, out-loud speech more often becomes muttering and whispering, then silent, though it can still be heard in many children in elementary school. Both roles remain: the one giving orders and the one obeying. They’re just in one head now.
Talking to yourself aloud while doing something isn’t a glitch but normal in preschool age: observers find it in almost every child
That’s why inner speech is so short and commanding. It doesn’t reason - it gives orders, because it grew out of orders.
How a phrase becomes a rule
A child doesn’t store the whole scene. She draws a conclusion about herself: if people talk to me like this, there must be something wrong with me. A particular case - a line at the store, strangers’ looks, a tired mother - gets condensed into a general rule.
Then the rule lives on without the original scene. That’s why as an adult, you’re more likely to remember the feeling than the episode it came from. From “don’t make things up” comes the belief that you can’t trust your own sensations and need to check with others first. From “what will people think” - that you’re always on display and have to keep a composed face whatever you feel. From “you could have done better” - that what you’ve done doesn’t count and the bar is always a little higher than where you are.
The ready-made rule surfaces when there’s no time to think: when you’re tired, in a rush, or being judged by someone else. Another typical moment is when you say something to a child yourself and hear someone else’s intonation in your voice. One caveat: the idea that a specific childhood phrase becomes an adult inner critic comes mainly from people’s accounts in therapy, and the strength of this link isn’t known. But the shift of speech from outside to inside can be seen directly in observations of children.
Finish reading in the Miqo app
1 more minute, then a quiz at the end. Find it under “Psychology → Childhood”
Point your phone camera here to open the App Store or Google Play.
Sources
- The idea that inner speech grows out of external speech: L. S. Vygotsky, Thought and Language, 1934. Laura Berk systematically observed children’s out-loud speech during tasks in the 1980s-90s